Guidelines to Reviewers

The Journal of Global Economy (JGE) is committed to a fair, constructive, confidential, and academically rigorous peer-review process. Reviewers play an important role in maintaining the quality and integrity of the journal and are expected to follow the principles below.

1. Confidentiality

Manuscripts received for review are confidential documents.

Reviewers should not share, copy, distribute, discuss, or use unpublished information from a manuscript for personal or professional advantage.

The identity of the authors and the contents of the manuscript should be treated confidentially throughout the review process.

2. Objectivity and Fairness

Reviews should be conducted objectively and impartially.

Reviewers should evaluate the manuscript on the basis of its:

  • originality and scholarly contribution;
  • relevance to the scope of JGE;
  • clarity of research objectives or questions;
  • appropriateness of methodology;
  • quality and interpretation of evidence;
  • validity of conclusions; and
  • overall academic quality.

Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate. Comments should be professional, specific, and constructive.

3. Reviewer Expertise

Reviewers should accept an assignment only when they have sufficient subject knowledge and expertise to provide a meaningful assessment.

If a reviewer believes that the manuscript falls substantially outside their area of expertise, they should inform the Editor promptly.

4. Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers should disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could affect their impartiality.

A reviewer should normally decline an assignment where they have a close personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationship with the authors or where other circumstances could reasonably compromise independent judgment.

If a conflict becomes apparent after accepting a manuscript, the reviewer should inform the Editor immediately.

5. Timeliness

Reviewers should complete reviews within the time period agreed with the journal.

If a reviewer is unable to complete the review within the specified period, they should inform the Editor as soon as possible.

Where appropriate, the reviewer may decline the assignment so that the journal can seek another reviewer without unnecessary delay.

6. Assessment of Originality and Research Integrity

Reviewers should alert the Editor if they identify substantial similarity between the manuscript and previously published work or have reasonable concerns about possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication, falsification, or other forms of academic misconduct.

Reviewers should not independently investigate or contact the authors about suspected misconduct unless specifically requested by the Editor.

7. Evaluation of Methodology and Evidence

Reviewers should assess whether the research methods are appropriate for addressing the stated objectives or research questions.

Where relevant, reviewers should consider:

  • the adequacy and appropriateness of the data;
  • research design;
  • sampling procedures;
  • measurement and variables;
  • statistical or econometric methods;
  • interpretation of results;
  • robustness of findings; and
  • whether the conclusions are supported by the evidence.

Reviewers should distinguish between major issues affecting the validity of the study and minor issues that can be addressed during revision.

8. Citations and Relevant Literature

Reviewers may recommend additional references where they are genuinely relevant and would materially improve the manuscript.

Reviewers should not recommend citations merely to increase citation counts or to promote their own work, the work of colleagues, or publications of JGE.

Authors should not be expected to cite a particular journal or individual as a condition of publication.

9. Constructive Feedback

A useful review should help authors improve their manuscript.

Reviewers are encouraged to identify both strengths and weaknesses and to provide clear suggestions for improvement.

Where a manuscript requires substantial revision, reviewers should explain the principal issues that need to be addressed rather than simply recommending rejection without adequate academic justification.

10. Recommendation to the Editor

The reviewer's recommendation should reflect the scholarly assessment of the manuscript.

Possible recommendations may include:

  • Accept;
  • Minor Revision;
  • Major Revision; or
  • Reject.

The recommendation should be supported by comments that explain the principal reasons for the decision.

The recommendation communicated to the Editor may be confidential and may differ from comments intended for the authors.

11. Unpublished Material and Intellectual Property

Reviewers must not use ideas, data, methods, arguments, or other unpublished material contained in a manuscript for their own research or professional advantage before the work has been published or otherwise made publicly available.

Any potential intellectual-property concern should be brought to the Editor's attention.

12. Use of Generative AI in Peer Review

Reviewers should not upload or disclose confidential manuscripts, unpublished research, personal information, or other confidential material to generative AI tools or other external systems where doing so could compromise confidentiality.

If AI-assisted tools are used in connection with reviewing, reviewers remain responsible for maintaining confidentiality and for the accuracy and appropriateness of any review they submit.

Reviewers should follow the journal's Policy on the Use of Generative AI (GenAI).

13. Communication with the Editor

Any confidential concerns that reviewers do not wish to communicate to the authors should be directed to the Editor.

Reviewers should inform the Editor of any circumstances that may affect the fairness, confidentiality, or integrity of the review.

14. Responsibility of Reviewers

By accepting a review assignment, reviewers agree to conduct the review honestly, independently, confidentially, and within the agreed timeframe.

The reviewer should remember that peer review is a scholarly responsibility intended to improve the quality of published research and contribute to the integrity of the academic record.